50+ Mentorship Program Survey Questions that Feed KPIs

Ask any of my colleagues at MentorcliQ to say one thing I love, and most will tell you it’s data. I just can’t get enough of it, especially for mentoring programs. Commonly, we find that mentorship program admins love data as much as we do. No wonder, as that data is essential to proving the value of the program and helping to benchmark toward KPIs. Not all data is alike, though, and mentorship program survey data falls into the “qualitative” data bucket. Even still, having the right mentorship program survey questions can make or break whether your data is good enough to ship to the executive team or as worthless as a chocolate teapot (think about it for a moment, then laugh).

When done well, mentorship program feedback surveys offer invaluable insights that allow for a thorough evaluation of how the program impacts both mentors and mentees. This feedback is not only essential for gauging the success of the program but also for identifying areas that may require improvements or adjustments mid- or post-cycles.

As James Cromwell’s character, Alfred Lanning, stated in one of my favorite sci-fi movies, “I, Robot”: if you want to get to the truth, “You must ask the right question.”

What Is a Mentorship Program Survey?

Mentorship program surveys are questionnaires of any length that you send out to mentoring program participants. While there are multiple types of mentoring program surveys that serve distinctly different purposes, they fall into two different flavor buckets:

1. Surveys for qualitative data
2. Surveys for quantitative data

By and large, most mentorship program surveys are designed to gather qualitative data, or data that helps us understand how someone feels or thinks about a topic. This would be expressed in a question such as, “How would you rate your experience of signing up for the mentoring program on a scale of 0-5?” That kind of question is looking to understand how people felt about the enrollment experience.

Conversely, surveys designed to get quantitative data are those looking to collect data on things you can count, such as “How many hours have you spent this week on mentoring?” There’s (usually) no personal opinion on that question; it’s just a quantifiable number, such as 5 hours.

How to Prepare Your Mentoring Survey Questions

If you want accurate data, you’ll need to take a structured and strategic approach long before you send out your surveys. Mentee and mentor surveys can focus on qualitative, quantitative, or both types data. It depends on what questions you’re trying to answer about your mentoring program. And that is always the order of operations here.

1. Define objectives and key questions: Start by clearly defining what you want to know about your mentoring program. Are you looking to improve engagement, assess effectiveness, or identify areas for improvement? Your objectives will guide the entire process.
2. Develop hypotheses: Based on your objectives, formulate hypotheses or assumptions. For instance, you might hypothesize that mentees with more frequent interactions report higher satisfaction. These hypotheses will help shape your survey questions.
3. Design survey questions: Create questions that directly address your key objectives and test your hypotheses. Be mindful of balancing qualitative and quantitative questions. Qualitative questions can provide rich, detailed insights, while quantitative questions are easier to measure and compare.
4. Establish measurement criteria: Before sending out the survey, decide how you’ll measure and interpret the responses. For quantitative questions, this might involve statistical methods, whereas qualitative responses might require thematic and sentiment analysis.
5. Pilot test the survey: Before rolling out the survey to a larger audience, consider a pilot test with a smaller group. This helps identify any issues with the questions or the survey structure.
6. Distribute the survey: Send your survey to the intended respondents. Ensure that your distribution method reaches your target audience effectively and consider reminders or follow-ups to maximize response rates. Automating this part of the process within your mentoring platform will save you considerable time and increase your response rates.
7. Analyze the data: After collecting the responses, analyze the data per your predefined measurement criteria. Look for trends, patterns, and insights that align with or challenge your initial hypotheses.
8. Report findings and recommendations: Present your findings in a way that’s actionable and aligned with your initial objectives. Highlight key insights and suggest concrete steps for program improvement.
9. Implement changes and monitor impact: Based on the findings, implement changes in your mentoring program. It’s important to monitor the impact of these changes over time to see if they’re effective.
10. Iterate the process: Finally, view this as an iterative process. Regularly revisiting and refining your survey and analysis approach will help you continuously improve your mentoring program.

This approach ensures that each process step is intentional and gets you closer to understanding whether you need to take action on your programs and provide the data you need to maintain internal support for programs or even to support scaling your programs more broadly across your organization.

Why Do Mentorship Program Survey Questions Matter?

Mentorship program surveys are one of the essential mentoring tools that can help improve the outcome of the program, and the survey questions are key to collecting crucial feedback. As mentors and mentees share their experiences and insights, it offers a window into the program’s effectiveness and areas needing attention.

The survey also helps assess the program’s overall success, especially if you establish KPIs at the outset to evaluate them upon completion. Most importantly, it provides insights into the mentor-mentee matching process, which can further help you refine the program strategies to ensure more effective and fruitful mentoring relationships.

This approach ensures that your mentorship program remains dynamic and continually evolves based on participant feedback to meet the objectives more effectively.

How to Create Mentorship Program Surveys

Your mentorship program feedback survey is an excellent tool for gathering meaningful thoughts from both mentors and mentees. This way, you’re not just guessing; you have real, actionable information to work with. One thing to note is that ‘feedback’ isn’t just for after the program starts. You can also use it to measure initial interest and find out what everyone’s hoping to get from the program before it even begins.

Before the program kicks off

This stage focuses on understanding the expectations and goals of participants. Survey questions should be geared towards identifying their reasons for joining, what they hope to gain, and any specific areas they wish to develop. This could include career aspirations, skill development, or networking goals.

Additionally, gauging their preferred learning styles and availability can help in creating more effective pairings. This survey should also include demographic questions to ensure a diverse and inclusive program. Feedback from this stage can shape the structure and content of the program, ensuring it meets the needs of the participants.

Survey questions to ask during registration

• What motivated you to join this mentorship program?
• What specific goals do you hope to achieve through this program?
• Can you describe the skills or areas you wish to develop during the mentorship?
• What is your preferred learning style (e.g., visual, auditory, hands-on)?
• What days and times are you typically available for mentoring sessions?
• Please provide some details about your professional background and interests.
• How do you hope this program will impact your career trajectory or personal development?

After pairing up

Once mentors and mentees are paired, a survey can help assess the suitability and comfort level of the pairings. Questions should focus on the initial impressions about the match, the clarity of roles and expectations, and any immediate concerns or suggestions for improvement.

This survey is crucial to catch and address any early issues in the pairing process. It should also probe into the planned frequency of meetings and preferred communication methods to establish a clear roadmap for the mentoring relationship.

Survey questions to ask after matching

• What are your initial impressions of your mentor/mentee?
• Do you feel the goals and expectations of this pairing are clear and aligned?
• Are there any immediate concerns or suggestions you have about your pairing?
• How often do you prefer to meet with your mentor/mentee?
• What communication methods work best for you (e.g., in-person, virtual, phone)?
• Is there anything specific you hope to learn or achieve through this particular pairing?

Following each mentoring session

Regular surveys after each session can track the progress and effectiveness of the mentorship. Survey questions should revolve around the usefulness of the session, the topics covered, and the quality of interaction between mentor and mentee. This is an opportunity to gather feedback on specific activities or discussions and make adjustments as needed. 

It’s also important to gauge the level of engagement and satisfaction from both parties, which can be critical indicators of the program’s success.

Survey questions to ask after each mentoring session

• How would you rate the overall effectiveness of this session?
• What topics were covered, and how relevant were they to your goals?
• How would you describe the interaction and communication during the session?
• Were there any specific activities or discussions that you found particularly beneficial?
• How engaged and satisfied do you feel after this session?
• Is there anything you wish to focus on or change for the next session?

Halfway through the program

A mid-point survey serves as a checkpoint to evaluate overall progress and satisfaction. Now, this survey should assess whether the initial goals are being met, the effectiveness of the mentoring strategies employed, and any changes or improvements needed.

It can delve into the development of the relationship between mentor and mentee, the relevance of the content discussed, and the perceived impact on the mentee’s personal and professional growth. Feedback from this stage can guide necessary adjustments for the remainder of the program.

Good news for you: We’ve got a Mid-Cycle Check-In template you can download and use right now!

Survey questions to ask halfway through the program

• How closely do you feel the program is aligning with your initial goals?
• What progress have you made in your personal and professional development?
• How effective do you find the mentoring strategies and approaches used so far?
• Can you describe how your relationship with your mentor/mentee has developed?
• Are there any adjustments or changes you would suggest for the second half of the program?
• How relevant and impactful have the discussions and activities been to your growth?

At the program’s conclusion

The final survey aims to evaluate the overall success and impact of the mentorship program. It should explore the achievement of initial goals, the quality of the mentoring relationship, and the long-term benefits perceived by both mentors and mentees.

This is also an opportunity to gather suggestions for future iterations of the program, including changes in structure, content, or support provided. The end-of-program survey should also encourage reflection on personal and professional growth experienced during the program.

Survey questions to ask when the program concludes

• Did the program meet your initial goals and expectations? Please elaborate.
• How would you rate the overall quality of your mentoring relationship?
• What are the most significant takeaways or benefits you’ve gained from this program?
• How has this program influenced your personal and professional growth?
• What suggestions do you have for future iterations of the program?
• Would you participate in this program again or recommend it to others? Why or why not?

Key areas to cover in your mentorship program survey

Formulating thoughtful questions will determine the kind of answers you get from program participants. Therefore, it is crucial to design survey questions to help you obtain the type of information you need. A good approach is to break down the mentoring program survey questions into different categories; each is designed to target specific areas of the mentor program. Therefore, mentors and mentees can find the right match and achieve their goals through this mentor program.

Survey questions about satisfaction with the program

Satisfaction survey questions aim to gauge overall contentment and the program’s effectiveness in meeting expectations. These questions assess the participant’s overall experience, willingness to recommend the program, and the clarity of goals. They are designed to elicit both quantitative ratings and qualitative feedback, providing insights into what works well and areas needing improvement. Responses help in understanding the program’s impact from a participant’s perspective and guiding future enhancements to increase satisfaction and effectiveness.

• Rate your overall satisfaction with the mentorship program on a scale of 1-5.
• Describe specific aspects of the mentoring program that exceeded your expectations.
• Would you recommend this mentorship program to others? Why or why not?
• Were the goals and objectives of your mentor-mentee relationship clear and attainable?
• What was the most valuable lesson or skill you gained from this program?
• Identify one area of the program that could be improved and suggest how.

Survey questions about personal and professional growth

These mentorship program survey questions probe into skills and knowledge acquired, career aspirations, and personal growth. They are tailored to understand how the program has contributed to each participant’s professional journey and personal development, including strengths, areas for improvement, and alignment of the program with individual career goals. Feedback gathered here is crucial for tailoring the program to better meet participants’ developmental needs.

• List three strengths you’ve developed during the program.
• Identify a professional skill you feel needs further development.
• Describe a personal or professional goal that this program has helped you move closer to achieving.
• How many years of experience do you have in your current field, and how has this program supported your career trajectory?
• Which specific skill sets or knowledge areas gained during the program do you find most valuable?

Survey questions about the quality of mentor-mentee relationships

This centers on the dynamics and effectiveness of the mentor-mentee relationship. Questions explore the comfort level, communication, and the evolution of the relationship over time. They seek to understand the quality of interactions, mutual respect, and the degree of learning and support exchanged. This feedback is vital for assessing the pairing process’s success and identifying areas to enhance relationship-building in future iterations of the program.

• On a scale of 1-5, how comfortable did you feel with your mentor/mentee?
• What specific qualities of your mentor/mentee did you find most beneficial?
• How has your relationship with your mentor/mentee evolved throughout the program?
• Share a memorable experience or lesson from your mentoring interactions.
• What changes, if any, would you suggest for enhancing mentor-mentee interactions in future programs?

Survey questions about program logistics and support

These questions evaluate the structural and logistical aspects of the program, from the adequacy of resources and the efficiency of the pairing process to the appropriateness of meeting frequency and overall program organization. This feedback helps identify logistical hurdles and streamline the program setup, which consequently helps in refining the registration process, resource allocation, and scheduling to ensure a seamless and productive experience for future participants.

• Were the resources and support provided during the program adequate and helpful?
• How could the mentor-mentee pairing process be improved?
• Was the frequency of meetings appropriate for your schedule, and would you prefer more or fewer sessions?
• Which program activities or discussions did you find most engaging?
• Provide feedback on the registration process and any logistical aspects of the program that could be streamlined.

Tips for Effective Survey Design

Designing and implementing mentorship program surveys is not an overnight project. It’s also not easily done alone, as you should always have someone to bounce ideas off of and make sure your logic makes sense. To get the most out of your surveys, take a step back and consider a few helpful tips first.

1. Incorporate a variety of question types for comprehensive insights

Use a mix of open-ended, Likert scale, and multiple-choice questions to enrich the survey. Open-ended questions provide depth and personal insights, while structured questions like Likert scales offer quantifiable data that are easier to analyze. This mix ensures a comprehensive understanding of participants’ experiences and opinions that balance detailed feedback with broad trends and patterns.

2. Avoid leading questions

Craft your survey questions in a neutral, unbiased manner to obtain genuine and objective responses. Leading questions subtly prompt a specific answer, can skew results, and diminish the survey’s reliability. Frame questions in a way that allows participants to express their true thoughts and feelings without any influence from the question’s wording or structure.

3. Maintain anonymity for authentic responses

Ensuring respondent anonymity is key to eliciting honest feedback, particularly in sensitive areas. When participants are assured that their responses are confidential and won’t be linked to their identity, they are more likely to provide genuine insights. This confidentiality encourages openness and trust, which leads to more accurate and valuable survey results.

4. Optimize survey distribution for engagement

Choosing the right moment and platform for distributing the survey significantly impacts the response rate and quality of feedback. Surveys should be sent when participants are likely to be receptive and not preoccupied, like during work hours or weekdays. Additionally, using familiar and easily accessible platforms increases participation, making the process convenient and user-friendly.

5. Use a Likert scale for accurate data collection and measurement

Incorporating Likert scales in your survey can significantly refine the precision and measurability of data regarding participants’ attitudes and experiences. These scales typically present statements with a range of response options, from “Strongly Agree” to “Strongly Disagree,” enabling you to capture the intensity and nuances of participants’ opinions. This approach transforms subjective viewpoints into quantifiable data, simplifying analysis and ensuring ease of comprehension for respondents, thus potentially increasing completion rates.

Additionally, the standardized format of Likert scales allows for consistent comparison across various questions and themes within your mentoring program. When crafting these scales, it’s important to maintain a balanced set of response choices, including neutral options, to minimize bias and accurately reflect participants’ true feelings.

6. Account for small populations where anonymity is impossible

Maintaining anonymity can be tricky when dealing with small populations in your mentoring program. In such cases, participants might be easily identifiable even without explicit personal information. To address this, try to adopt strategies that protect individual privacy while still collecting valuable feedback.

One approach is to aggregate responses in your reporting, presenting data in groups or themes rather than individual answers. Also, consider using broader questions focusing on general experiences rather than specific incidents. This not only helps in safeguarding anonymity but also encourages candid responses. If feasible, you could also assure participants that results will only be reviewed by a select few individuals who are committed to maintaining confidentiality.

Fostering a culture of trust and emphasizing the survey’s goal of improving the program can reassure participants about the positive intent and secure use of their responses. When you can’t guarantee anonymity because the respondent population is small, be honest about that. Those individuals who know they can’t be anonymous may choose not to respond. Yes, that may mess up your data collection, but if anonymity is important to your program, it’s better to take the hit to visibility than a hit to trust.

7. Leverage mentoring software for efficiency

Building a survey can be tedious as it requires careful consideration of various factors to ensure that the survey is effective and yields useful data. Getting to the heart of whether your program is getting results is exciting, even when the results show that it’s not. After all, knowing that your program isn’t work is just as important as knowing that it is.

And that, detective, is the right question.

The right tool for the job, however, is one that completely automates your mentorship program surveys. For that, MentorcliQ has you covered.

Our mentoring software includes features for customizing surveys, automating distribution, and efficiently analyzing responses. You can integrate feedback directly into the mentoring program, provide real-time insights, and facilitate continuous improvement based on participants’ experiences and suggestions.

Do a quick click here to watch a quick flick about our QuickcliQs.